Selective InsuranceSIGI.OValuation Analysis
Based on the blended 10-year P/E and P/B percentiles, the stock currently sits in the “Deeply Undervalued” zone.
As of Oct 16, 2026, Selective Insurance (SIGI.O) trades at a P/E of 10.90x, P/B of 1.45x, P/S of 0.97x, and a dividend yield of 1.44%.
Longitudinal percentile comparison: P/E sits at the 3rd percentile over the trailing 10Y window (vs. 8th percentile over 3Y); P/B sits at the 12th percentile over the trailing 10Y window (vs. 26th percentile over 3Y); P/S sits at the 9th percentile over the trailing 10Y window (vs. 29th percentile over 3Y).
Cross-sectional valuation: its P/E ranks at the 26th percentile within its industry and the 22nd percentile across the broader market.
Shareholder return highlight: Total Shareholder Yield is 3.18%, ranking at the 76th percentile over the trailing 20Y window.
Cross-checking P/E against P/B, the two percentiles sit within 8.8 points of each other — a consistent signal from both angles. Its P/E percentile is roughly the same whether measured against the industry or the broader market. Of the 3.18% total shareholder yield, 1.44% is paid out as dividends and roughly 1.74% is implied to come from buybacks — both channels are meaningfully in play. Selective Insurance operates in the Finance, Insurance, And Real Estate sector. Data refreshes weekly and is for reference only, not investment advice.
Also listed as: NASDAQ: SIGI · SIGI
Want the full picture on whether Selective Insurance (SIGI.O) is under- or over-valued? See the full 3Y / 5Y / 10Y / 20Y P/E, P/B, P/S, Dividend Yield & Total Shareholder Yield percentile matrix and the interactive ECharts trend chart on this page.
Historical Percentiles by Metric
| Metric | Current | Market Percentile | Industry Percentile | 3Y Pctl | 5Y Pctl | 10Y Pctl | 20Y Pctl |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P/E (TTM) | 10.90 | ||||||
| P/B (MRQ) | 1.45 | ||||||
| P/S (TTM) | 0.97 | ||||||
| Dividend Yield | 1.44% | ||||||
| Buyback + Div Yield | 3.18% |